Email marketing in the US: CAN-SPAM and the Gmail and Yahoo sender rules

Two sets of rules decide whether your marketing email is lawful and whether it arrives at all. One is a US law; the other is set by the mailbox providers. Both are simpler than they look.

A black envelope outline on bone, its flap drawn as a fine line, with a small amber square where a stamp would be.
Illustration: Polayads.

Email is still one of the most direct ways for a small business to stay in touch with customers and prospects. It is also governed by two separate sets of rules. The first is the law: in the United States, the CAN-SPAM Act. The second is the mailbox providers’ own requirements. Since February 2024, Gmail and Yahoo have required senders to prove who they are and to make unsubscribing easy, and mail that doesn’t meet those requirements is more likely to be filtered or rejected.

This article covers both in plain terms. It is general information, not legal advice, and it is about US rules only. If you email people in other countries, their laws may ask more of you.

Which emails the law covers

CAN-SPAM applies to commercial messages: emails whose primary purpose is to advertise or promote a product or service. The Federal Trade Commission is explicit on two points that surprise many businesses:

  • There is no exception for business-to-business email. A message to a company address is covered in the same way as one to a consumer.
  • It isn’t only about bulk email. A single promotional message to a former customer is covered.

Transactional and relationship messages, such as order confirmations, receipts, warranty or safety information and account changes, are exempt from most of the rules, though they still must not use false or misleading routing information. The FTC reads these categories narrowly: an existing relationship with someone doesn’t make a promotional email transactional. When a message mixes the two, what counts is its primary purpose, judged by the subject line and by what comes first and most prominently in the body.

What every marketing email must do

RequirementIn practice
Honest header informationThe From, To and Reply-To details identify your business accurately.
An honest subject lineIt reflects what the email is actually about.
Say it is an advertisementClearly and conspicuously. The law is flexible about how.
A valid physical postal addressA street address, a post office box registered with the US Postal Service, or a private mailbox registered with a commercial mail receiving agency.
A clear way to opt outA visible explanation and a working reply address or simple web page. You can offer topic choices, but one option must stop all marketing email.
Honour opt-outs quicklyWithin 10 business days. The opt-out must keep working for at least 30 days after you send, with no fee and no more than an email address asked for.
Watch who sends for youHiring an agency or platform doesn’t transfer your responsibility. Both can be held liable.
The main CAN-SPAM requirements, summarised from the FTC’s compliance guide.

The penalties are serious. The FTC’s guide puts the maximum civil penalty at $53,088 for each separate email that breaks the law, so a careless campaign can become very expensive very quickly.

Key takeaway

Every promotional email needs a real sender, an honest subject line, a postal address and a working unsubscribe that you honour within 10 business days.

What Gmail and Yahoo now expect

The law sets a minimum. Whether your email reaches the inbox depends on the mailbox providers, and Gmail and Yahoo now set clear requirements. Google’s apply to anyone sending to personal Gmail accounts; both companies add stricter rules for bulk senders, which Google defines as sending more than 5,000 messages a day to Gmail addresses.

All sendersBulk senders
AuthenticationSPF or DKIM on the sending domainSPF and DKIM, plus a DMARC record (a policy of “none” is acceptable), with the From domain aligned
UnsubscribingAn easy way to opt out (and CAN-SPAM requires one)One-click unsubscribe in the message headers, plus a visible link in the body; Yahoo asks for requests to be processed within two days
Spam complaintsBelow 0.3% in Google Postmaster ToolsBelow 0.3%; Google recommends staying under 0.1%
Technical basicsValid forward and reverse DNS, an encrypted (TLS) connection, correctly formatted messagesThe same
Gmail and Yahoo sender requirements, from Google’s email sender guidelines and the Yahoo Sender Hub.

If those terms are unfamiliar, the idea is simple. SPF lists the servers allowed to send email for your domain. DKIM adds a signature proving a message wasn’t altered. DMARC tells receiving servers what to do when a message claiming to be from you fails those checks, and sends you reports about it. They are DNS settings, and most email platforms give you the exact records to add.

The law decides whether you may send an email. The mailbox providers decide whether anyone sees it.

A practical checklist

  • Send from your own domain, not a free mailbox, and set up SPF, DKIM and DMARC for it, even if you are a small sender.
  • Keep cold outreach away from your main domain. Many businesses send prospecting email from a separate, clearly related domain so that complaints can’t affect delivery of everyday email such as invoices and replies.
  • Use a reputable sending platform that adds one-click unsubscribe headers and processes opt-outs automatically.
  • Put your postal address and an unsubscribe link in your template once, so no campaign can go out without them.
  • Write subject lines you would be happy to defend. No fake “Re:” or “Fwd:” and no promises the email doesn’t keep.
  • Email people who expect to hear from you. Purchased lists bring complaints, and complaints are what push a sender towards the spam folder.
  • Watch your complaint rate. Google Postmaster Tools is free and shows how Gmail sees your domain.
  • Remove addresses that bounce or never engage. A smaller list of interested people delivers better than a large, tired one.

Checklist

  • Lawful: honest headers and subjects, an ad disclosure, a postal address, a working opt-out honoured in 10 business days.
  • Deliverable: SPF, DKIM and DMARC, one-click unsubscribe, complaints below 0.1%.
  • Sustainable: permission-based lists, kept clean.

Sources

Share this article