Most small businesses can add an advertising pixel or an analytics script to their website without a second thought. A therapy, counselling or health practice can’t. A tool that records which pages a visitor viewed, what they typed into a form or which appointment they booked may be sending sensitive health information to a third party, and US regulators have taken action over exactly that.
This article explains the rules in plain terms for small practices. It is general information, not legal advice; for decisions about your own practice, speak to a healthcare privacy lawyer or compliance adviser.
Does HIPAA apply to your practice?
HIPAA applies to “covered entities”, which include health care providers who transmit health information electronically in connection with certain standard transactions, such as submitting insurance claims or checking eligibility. That is true whether you do it yourself or through a billing service. A practice that is purely private-pay and never conducts those transactions electronically may not be a covered entity.
That doesn’t mean a practice outside HIPAA is free to share health information. The Federal Trade Commission enforces its own rules, and has used them against online health services, as the next sections show.
Key takeaway
Whether or not HIPAA applies, treat anything that reveals someone is seeking care as sensitive.
Tracking technologies and the 2024 court ruling
In guidance first issued in December 2022, the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office for Civil Rights (OCR) explained how HIPAA applies to tracking technologies such as pixels, cookies and session-recording scripts on the websites and apps of covered entities.
- Pages behind a login, such as patient portals, generally hold protected health information. Tracking there is the clearest risk.
- A vendor that receives protected health information on a covered entity’s behalf must sign a business associate agreement. If a tracking vendor won’t, the tool shouldn’t receive that information.
- Sharing protected health information for marketing without a patient’s HIPAA-compliant authorisation isn’t permitted.
In June 2024 a federal court in Texas, in a case brought by the American Hospital Association, vacated one part of that guidance: the position that combining a visitor’s IP address with a visit to a public, unauthenticated page about a health condition or provider was, on its own, enough to involve protected health information. HHS later withdrew its appeal. The rest of the guidance, including what it says about logged-in pages, was not set aside.
The ruling narrowed the federal position; it didn’t make tracking safe. Booking flows, intake forms and portals remain sensitive, and state privacy laws and private lawsuits don’t depend on the HHS guidance.
What the FTC has done
In March 2023 the FTC announced action against BetterHelp, an online counselling service. The FTC said the company had shared consumers’ email addresses, IP addresses and health questionnaire information with platforms including Facebook and Snapchat for advertising, after promising to keep such data private. The company agreed to pay $7.8 million, and the order banned it from sharing consumers’ health data for advertising.
The FTC also enforces the Health Breach Notification Rule, which covers many health apps and services that aren’t covered by HIPAA. Its guidance is explicit that a breach isn’t limited to hacking: disclosing someone’s identifiable health information without their authorisation counts too. Amendments in July 2024 made clear that health apps and similar products must comply.
On a health website, the riskiest code is often the marketing code.
A practical approach for a practice website
| Area | Safer approach |
|---|---|
| Advertising pixels | Keep them off booking, intake, portal and condition-specific pages, or leave them out entirely |
| Analytics | Choose a privacy-focused configuration or tool, collect as little as possible, and check where the data goes |
| Contact forms | Ask only for what’s needed to reply; tell people not to include clinical details; send to a secure inbox |
| Booking and intake | Use a healthcare-specific platform that will sign a business associate agreement if HIPAA applies to you |
| Embedded tools | Check chat widgets, maps, videos and fonts for what they collect about visitors |
| Privacy policy | Describe accurately what the site collects and shares, and keep it current |
- Audit what your site loads. Many sites run scripts nobody remembers adding, from an old ad campaign or a plugin.
- Read vendors’ terms. If a booking or form tool won’t sign a business associate agreement, and HIPAA applies to you, choose another.
- Make crisis information easy to find. Many practice sites point people in immediate danger to the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline; it’s a small addition that matters.
- Write the privacy policy last, once you know exactly what the site does, and update it whenever that changes.
Checklist
- Know whether HIPAA applies to you.
- Keep ad pixels away from anything that reveals care.
- Use vendors that will sign a business associate agreement where needed.
- Collect less in forms.
- Audit scripts, then write an accurate privacy policy.
Related service
Websites for practices and service businesses, built with privacy in mind.
Sources
- US Department of Health and Human Services: Summary of the HIPAA Privacy Rule
- HHS Office for Civil Rights: Use of online tracking technologies by HIPAA covered entities and business associates
- American Hospital Association: HHS will not appeal court ruling in online tracking case (August 2024)
- Federal Trade Commission: FTC to ban BetterHelp from revealing consumers’ data (March 2023)
- Federal Trade Commission: Complying with the FTC’s Health Breach Notification Rule



