How to choose a web design company: 15 questions to ask

Most web design companies can show you a nice portfolio. Far fewer can explain how your website will win customers, who will own it, and what it will cost to run. These questions help you tell the difference before you sign.

A black checklist outline on bone with three ticked boxes, the last tick in amber, beside a browser window outline.
Illustration: Polayads.

A new website is one of the bigger marketing decisions a small business makes, and the company you choose shapes everything that follows: how the site looks, how well it brings in enquiries, and how easy it is to change later. Price matters, but it’s rarely the best way to choose. Ask good questions instead.

A diagram of five areas to ask a web design company about: their work, their process, ownership, costs, and support after launch, each with an example question.
Five areas to cover before you hire. Diagram: Polayads.

Their work

  • Can you show me sites you’ve built for businesses like mine? Look at live sites, not just screenshots. Open them on your phone.
  • What did those sites achieve? A good company can talk about goals and outcomes, not only design. Be wary of results that can’t be explained or checked.
  • Can I speak to a past client? A short call tells you more than any testimonial.

Their process

  • Who will actually work on my project? Ask who designs, who builds and who you’ll talk to week to week.
  • How do you plan the site before designing it? Expect questions about your customers, services and goals, not only colors and logos.
  • Who writes the content? Words and photos are often what delays a launch. Agree who does what, in writing.
  • How many rounds of feedback are included? And what happens if you need more?

Key takeaway

A company that asks you lots of questions about your customers is usually a better sign than one that starts with a mood board.

Ownership

  • Who will own the domain, hosting account, design and code? You should. Our guides to owning your domain and who owns your logo and website explain why.
  • Can I move the site to another provider later? If the answer is no, you’re renting, not buying.
  • Will we be able to update it ourselves? Ask for a short demonstration of editing a page.

Costs

  • What exactly is included in the price? Pages, features, content, photography, set-up and testing.
  • What will it cost to run each year? Domain, hosting, licences and support, at renewal prices. Our website cost guide sets out the usual items.

Search, accessibility and support

  • How will the site be set up for search? Expect answers about page titles, structure, speed and your Google Business Profile, not promises about rankings.
  • Is accessibility tested? Ask which standard they work to; WCAG 2.2 AA is a sensible target. Our ADA guide explains why it matters.
  • What support do you offer after launch? Updates, backups, fixes and small changes: what’s included, and what costs extra.

No one can promise you the top spot on Google, and anyone who does is a warning sign.

Warning signs

  • Guaranteed rankings. Google’s own guidance on hiring an SEO says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking.
  • The domain or hosting registered in the provider’s name, not yours.
  • No written scope: just a price and a launch date.
  • A very low price with no mention of content, testing or support.
  • Pressure to sign quickly, or vague answers about who does the work.

Comparing proposals

CheckWhy it matters
Scope in writingYou can see exactly what you’re paying for, and compare like with like
Ownership statedYou can move, change or rebuild the site later without starting again
Running costs listedNo surprises at renewal
Who does the contentThe most common cause of delays and extra cost
Support after launchWebsites need updates and fixes; agree how they’re handled
What a clear proposal should show.

Checklist

  • Look at real work on your phone.
  • Ask who does what, including content.
  • Get ownership in writing.
  • Budget with yearly running costs.
  • Avoid anyone who guarantees rankings.

Planning a redesign rather than a first website? Start with our checklist for redesigning a website.

Sources

Share this article