Website builders such as Wix, Squarespace and the builders bundled with hosting have made it possible for anyone to publish a good looking site. So why do businesses still pay web designers? Because looking good and bringing in work aren’t the same thing, and because the real cost of a website isn’t only the price tag. Here’s an honest comparison.

When a website builder is the right call
- You’re testing a new idea and need something online this month.
- Your budget is very small, and a simple site is better than none.
- You need one or two pages, and most customers come from referrals anyway.
- You enjoy the work and have the time to do it well.
If that’s you, a builder is a sensible choice. Our comparison of WordPress, Wix and Squarespace can help you pick one.
When hiring someone pays back
- Your website is, or should be, your main source of new customers.
- You offer several services or serve several areas, so you need a proper page structure.
- You’ve built a site yourself and it isn’t bringing in enquiries.
- You work in health, legal, finance or another regulated field, where wording, privacy and forms need care.
- Your time is worth more spent on the business than on learning web design.
Key takeaway
A builder gives you a website. A good designer gives you a website that’s planned to bring in work.
The costs people forget
Comparing a monthly subscription with a one time design fee hides most of the real cost. On both sides, count:
- Your hours. Building, writing, choosing images and fixing things takes time, and time is the cost owners most often underestimate.
- Subscriptions and add ons. Builder plans renew every year, and booking tools, forms, stores or removing branding can mean a higher plan or paid apps.
- Words and photos. Neither option writes your copy or takes your photos unless you pay for that. Good content matters more than the platform.
- Looking after it. Someone has to keep the site updated, secure and accurate, whichever way you build it.
- Rebuilding later. A site that doesn’t work often gets rebuilt within a couple of years, which is the most expensive outcome of all.
Ownership and moving later
Builders host your site on their platform, and leaving can mean rebuilding it. Squarespace, for example, exports only some types of content, as a file for importing into WordPress. Before you commit to any builder, read its help page on exporting your site.
If you hire a designer, make sure the domain and hosting are in your name, and that you get the logins and files at handover. See why you should own your domain name and how to choose a web design company.
The cheapest website is the one that brings in work. The most expensive is the one nobody calls from.
There’s a middle path
- Pay a designer to plan and set up your site on a builder, then run it yourself.
- Have a site built on WordPress that your team can edit, with optional help afterwards.
- Choose a fixed price package, so you know the total before you start.
Five questions that usually settle it
- How many new customers should the website bring in each month?
- How many services and areas does it need to cover?
- How many hours can you realistically give it, now and every month?
- Do you work in a field with rules about advertising, privacy or claims?
- If you had to move the site in three years, could you?
If your answers point to a builder, use one. If they point to a designer, compare quotes carefully: ask for a written page list and inclusions. Our own fixed price packages start at $1,499, and if a builder would serve you better, we’ll tell you.
Checklist
- A builder suits simple sites, small budgets and owners with time.
- A designer pays back when the site must bring in work.
- Count your hours, subscriptions, content and upkeep.
- Check how you would move the site before you start.
- Keep the domain in your name either way.
Related service
Fixed price websites for small businesses, planned to bring in calls and enquiries, with the domain and hosting in your name.



